Between Benefit in Kind tax, National Insurance and restricted VAT recovery, a company car can sometimes cost far more than people expect.
Here’s a simple guide to how the rules actually work.
1. If the company provides the car
The company can claim:
Lease payments OR capital allowances if purchased (Relief against tax)
Insurance
Servicing and maintenance
Road Tax
Fuel (if provided)
These are deductible business expenses.
However…
2. The director or employee usually pays tax
If the car is available for private use, HMRC treats it as a Benefit in Kind (BIK).
This means:
The director/employee pays income tax on the benefit
The company pays Employer’s NI (15% from April 2025)
The tax is based on:
The list price of the car
The CO2 emissions
3. Electric cars are usually the best option
Electric vehicles currently have very low BIK rates (only 4% in 26/27).
For example:
Electric car BIK rate is currently very low compared to petrol/diesel. This can make company ownership far more tax-efficient.
This is why many directors are choosing electric company cars.
4. Fuel for private use creates another tax charge
If the company pays for private fuel, there is an additional benefit charge.
This is often very expensive, so many people avoid this.
Instead they:
Pay for private fuel themselves
Claim business mileage
5. Sometimes a personal car is better
In some situations, it’s more tax-efficient to:
Own the car personally
Claim 45p per mile for business travel
This avoids Benefit in Kind tax completely.
6. What about VAT on company cars?
VAT recovery on cars is very restricted, so many businesses are surprised by this.
If the company buys a car
In most cases:
You cannot reclaim the VAT on the purchase price.
This is because HMRC assumes the car will have some private use.
The only situations where VAT may be reclaimed are when the car is:
Used exclusively for business
Not available for private use
Normally kept at business premises overnight
This is quite difficult to prove, so most businesses cannot reclaim VAT on the purchase of a car.
If the company leases a car
VAT rules are different for leases.
Usually:
50% of the VAT on the lease payments can be reclaimed
This restriction exists because HMRC assumes some private use.
However:
100% of the VAT can usually be reclaimed on maintenance costs within the lease.
VAT on fuel
If the company pays for fuel:
VAT can be reclaimed on business fuel
But if fuel is also used privately, you must either:
Keep detailed mileage records and reclaim only business fuel VAT
OR
Apply the fuel scale charge
Many businesses avoid this by simply paying for private fuel themselves.
Simple rule of thumb
A company car can be great, but the tax impact needs checking first:
VAT recovery is usually restricted
BIK tax often applies
The type of vehicle has a huge impact